blog

Your Accountant Made an Error with Your Payroll Taxes: Will You Get in Trouble?

Nobody likes doing taxes. When you have a business to run, you have other things to worry about—plus, you’d rather hire a professional to take care of complex payroll taxes. But what happens if the accountant or payroll service you hired makes a mistake on your tax return? The IRS has started cracking down on employers with outstanding tax liabilities, so you could end up in a bad situation.

You Are Liable for Tax Return Mistakes

Although you hired an accountant to do your taxes, it’s your tax return with your name on it. It’s your responsibility. If there’s an error, it’s on you, not your accountant. If the IRS adjusts your tax liability and determines that you owe more money, you have to pay it, not your accountant. You’re also on the hook for any penalties and interest.

What to Do If Your Bookkeeper Makes an Error on Your Return

If you or your accountant notices a payroll tax error, you should work together to fix the mistake as soon as possible. The accountant should offer to file an amended return for you at no extra charge if the mistake was on their end. The relevant form is 941-X, the Adjusted Employer’s Quarterly Federal Tax Return. You can file a 941-X to notify the IRS of any over or underreporting of your payroll taxes and start the adjustment process.

As of 2022, the IRS is taking a harsher stance against employers who do not remit a 941-X for mistakes on their tax returns. Those with outstanding liabilities will have to answer to one of the IRS’s revenue officers to remedy the situation. It’s possible the revenue officer will also refer you to the criminal investigation division if they determine a crime has been committed.

You have a lot to lose if you discover and do not attempt to rectify mistakes with your payroll taxes. Any past issues can come back to haunt you, as the IRS has three years to assess tax liability against an officer of the business and ten years before the liability even expires.

Proving Negligence

Many companies use payroll services to handle their employment taxes, rather than a single accountant. If you notice a discrepancy from this service, they could be held accountable, not you. The payroll service may have been withholding taxes but failing to forward them to the IRS appropriately.

If you want to claim negligence on the part of your accountant or payroll service for errors with your payroll taxes, you will have to demonstrate:

  1. The accountant had a legal duty of care to you.
  2. The accountant breached that duty.
  3. The breach caused harm to you.
  4. The accountant’s negligence resulted in damages to you.

Work With an Experienced Maryland Tax Attorney

When you run a business, you want to stay out of trouble with the IRS. You could face strict and drawn-out consequences on both your business and personal finances if you don’t. If you find yourself with an erroneous tax return, working with an experienced tax attorney could help you save time and money. For more information about how Gabaie & Associates, LLC can assist you, call us at (410) 358-1300 today.

share
    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Contact Our Firm

    By providing my phone number to Gabaie & Associates LLC, I agree and acknowledge that Gabaie & Associates LLC may send text messages to my wireless phone number for any purpose. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency will vary, and you can opt-out by replying "STOP".

    For more information on how your data will be handled, please visit Privacy Policy

    Contact Us Today!
    Time is of the essence when it comes to tax-related issues. If you are uncertain as to what your next step should be, contact the reliable tax attorneys at Gabaie & Associates, LLC today.
    Office Locations
    Baltimore Office
    115 Sudbrook Lane , Suite 206
    Baltimore, MD 21208

    800.918.2270 (fax)

    Columbia Office
    10320 Little Patuxent Parkway Suite 200
    Columbia, MD 21044

    800.918.2270 (fax)

    3 more locations

    The information contained in this website is provided for informational purposes only and may not reflect the most current legal developments, and should not be construed as legal advice on any matter. The transmission and receipt of information contained on this Web site, in whole or in part, or communication with Gabaie & Associates, LLC via the Internet or e-mail through this website does not constitute or create a lawyer-client relationship between us and any recipient. You should not send us any confidential information in response to this webpage. Such responses will not create a lawyer-client relationship, and whatever you disclose to us will not be privileged or confidential unless we have agreed to act as your legal counsel and you have executed a written engagement agreement with Gabaie & Associates, LLC. Contact a licensed attorney for advice in specific legal issues.

    Connect
    Copyright © 2025 Gabaie & Associates, LLC